{
  "generated_utc": "2026-09-07T13:33:57.175736+00:00",
  "design": {
    "categories": [
      "project management software"
    ],
    "shapes": {
      "best": [
        "What is the best {cat} for a small business?",
        "Best {cat} in 2026?"
      ],
      "alternatives": [
        "What are the best alternatives to {A}?",
        "{A} alternatives for a small team"
      ],
      "vs": [
        "{A} vs {B}: which should I choose?",
        "Is {A} or {B} better for a small business?"
      ]
    },
    "models": [
      "google/gemini-2.5-flash:online",
      "openai/gpt-4o:online",
      "perplexity/sonar"
    ],
    "repeats": 3,
    "prompts": 30,
    "calls": 18
  },
  "by_shape": {
    "best": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 57,
      "citations_per_answer": 9.5,
      "unique_urls": 42,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "listicle": 0.842,
        "other": 0.14,
        "comparison": 0.018
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.667,
        "vendor": 0.175,
        "directory": 0.088,
        "community": 0.07
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.614,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.123,
        "other|vendor": 0.053,
        "listicle|directory": 0.053,
        "listicle|community": 0.053,
        "other|media-blog": 0.035,
        "other|directory": 0.035,
        "other|community": 0.018,
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.018
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "listicle": 0.614,
        "other": 0.386
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "alternatives": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 59,
      "citations_per_answer": 9.83,
      "unique_urls": 40,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.864,
        "other": 0.119,
        "listicle": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.644,
        "vendor": 0.271,
        "community": 0.068,
        "directory": 0.017
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.542,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.237,
        "other|media-blog": 0.102,
        "comparison|community": 0.068,
        "comparison|directory": 0.017,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.017,
        "other|vendor": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.847,
        "other": 0.136,
        "listicle": 0.017
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.237
    },
    "vs": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 60,
      "citations_per_answer": 10.0,
      "unique_urls": 34,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.983,
        "other": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.783,
        "directory": 0.083,
        "vendor": 0.083,
        "community": 0.05
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.783,
        "comparison|directory": 0.083,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.083,
        "comparison|community": 0.033,
        "other|community": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.983,
        "other": 0.017
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.083
    }
  },
  "by_shape_x_model": {
    "best|perplexity/sonar": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 37,
      "citations_per_answer": 18.5,
      "unique_urls": 36,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "listicle": 0.838,
        "other": 0.162
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.595,
        "vendor": 0.162,
        "directory": 0.135,
        "community": 0.108
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.541,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.135,
        "listicle|directory": 0.081,
        "listicle|community": 0.081,
        "other|media-blog": 0.054,
        "other|directory": 0.054,
        "other|community": 0.027,
        "other|vendor": 0.027
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "listicle": 0.568,
        "other": 0.432
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "best|openai/gpt-4o:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 10,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "listicle": 0.8,
        "other": 0.1,
        "comparison": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.8,
        "vendor": 0.2
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.7,
        "other|vendor": 0.1,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.1,
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "listicle": 0.7,
        "other": 0.3
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "best|google/gemini-2.5-flash:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 10,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "listicle": 0.9,
        "other": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.8,
        "vendor": 0.2
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.8,
        "other|vendor": 0.1,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "listicle": 0.7,
        "other": 0.3
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "alternatives|perplexity/sonar": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 39,
      "citations_per_answer": 19.5,
      "unique_urls": 27,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.974,
        "listicle": 0.026
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.538,
        "vendor": 0.333,
        "community": 0.103,
        "directory": 0.026
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.538,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.308,
        "comparison|community": 0.103,
        "comparison|directory": 0.026,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.026
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.974,
        "listicle": 0.026
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.308
    },
    "alternatives|openai/gpt-4o:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 10,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.7,
        "other": 0.3
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.8,
        "vendor": 0.2
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.6,
        "other|media-blog": 0.2,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.1,
        "other|vendor": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.6,
        "other": 0.4
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.1
    },
    "alternatives|google/gemini-2.5-flash:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 10,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.6,
        "other": 0.4
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.9,
        "vendor": 0.1
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.5,
        "other|media-blog": 0.4,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.6,
        "other": 0.4
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.1
    },
    "vs|perplexity/sonar": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 40,
      "citations_per_answer": 20.0,
      "unique_urls": 26,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.975,
        "other": 0.025
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.7,
        "vendor": 0.125,
        "directory": 0.1,
        "community": 0.075
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.7,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.125,
        "comparison|directory": 0.1,
        "comparison|community": 0.05,
        "other|community": 0.025
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.975,
        "other": 0.025
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.125
    },
    "vs|openai/gpt-4o:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 9,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 1.0
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.9,
        "directory": 0.1
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.9,
        "comparison|directory": 0.1
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 1.0
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "vs|google/gemini-2.5-flash:online": {
      "answers": 2,
      "citations": 10,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 10,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 1.0
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 1.0
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 1.0
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 1.0
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    }
  },
  "by_shape_x_category": {
    "best|project management software": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 57,
      "citations_per_answer": 9.5,
      "unique_urls": 42,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "listicle": 0.842,
        "other": 0.14,
        "comparison": 0.018
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.667,
        "vendor": 0.175,
        "directory": 0.088,
        "community": 0.07
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.614,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.123,
        "other|vendor": 0.053,
        "listicle|directory": 0.053,
        "listicle|community": 0.053,
        "other|media-blog": 0.035,
        "other|directory": 0.035,
        "other|community": 0.018,
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.018
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "listicle": 0.614,
        "other": 0.386
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.0
    },
    "alternatives|project management software": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 59,
      "citations_per_answer": 9.83,
      "unique_urls": 40,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.864,
        "other": 0.119,
        "listicle": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.644,
        "vendor": 0.271,
        "community": 0.068,
        "directory": 0.017
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.542,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.237,
        "other|media-blog": 0.102,
        "comparison|community": 0.068,
        "comparison|directory": 0.017,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.017,
        "other|vendor": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.847,
        "other": 0.136,
        "listicle": 0.017
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.237
    },
    "vs|project management software": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 60,
      "citations_per_answer": 10.0,
      "unique_urls": 34,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.983,
        "other": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.783,
        "directory": 0.083,
        "vendor": 0.083,
        "community": 0.05
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.783,
        "comparison|directory": 0.083,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.083,
        "comparison|community": 0.033,
        "other|community": 0.017
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.983,
        "other": 0.017
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.083
    }
  },
  "by_model": {
    "perplexity/sonar": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 116,
      "citations_per_answer": 19.33,
      "unique_urls": 89,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.664,
        "listicle": 0.276,
        "other": 0.06
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.612,
        "vendor": 0.207,
        "community": 0.095,
        "directory": 0.086
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.422,
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.172,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.147,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.052,
        "comparison|community": 0.052,
        "comparison|directory": 0.043,
        "listicle|directory": 0.026,
        "listicle|community": 0.026,
        "other|community": 0.017,
        "other|media-blog": 0.017,
        "other|directory": 0.017,
        "other|vendor": 0.009
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.664,
        "listicle": 0.19,
        "other": 0.147
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.147
    },
    "openai/gpt-4o:online": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 30,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 29,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.6,
        "listicle": 0.267,
        "other": 0.133
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.833,
        "vendor": 0.133,
        "directory": 0.033
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.533,
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.233,
        "other|vendor": 0.067,
        "other|media-blog": 0.067,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.033,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.033,
        "comparison|directory": 0.033
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.533,
        "listicle": 0.233,
        "other": 0.233
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.033
    },
    "google/gemini-2.5-flash:online": {
      "answers": 6,
      "citations": 30,
      "citations_per_answer": 5.0,
      "unique_urls": 30,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.533,
        "listicle": 0.3,
        "other": 0.167
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.9,
        "vendor": 0.1
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.5,
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.267,
        "other|media-blog": 0.133,
        "other|vendor": 0.033,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.033,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.033
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.533,
        "listicle": 0.233,
        "other": 0.233
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.033
    }
  },
  "overall": {
    "all": {
      "answers": 18,
      "citations": 176,
      "citations_per_answer": 9.78,
      "unique_urls": 116,
      "share_by_page_shape": {
        "comparison": 0.631,
        "listicle": 0.278,
        "other": 0.091
      },
      "share_by_source_type": {
        "media-blog": 0.699,
        "vendor": 0.176,
        "community": 0.062,
        "directory": 0.062
      },
      "share_shape_x_source": {
        "comparison|media-blog": 0.455,
        "listicle|media-blog": 0.199,
        "comparison|vendor": 0.108,
        "other|media-blog": 0.045,
        "listicle|vendor": 0.045,
        "comparison|community": 0.034,
        "comparison|directory": 0.034,
        "other|vendor": 0.023,
        "listicle|directory": 0.017,
        "listicle|community": 0.017,
        "other|community": 0.011,
        "other|directory": 0.011
      },
      "share_by_page_shape_path_only": {
        "comparison": 0.619,
        "listicle": 0.205,
        "other": 0.176
      },
      "vendor_owned_comparison_share": 0.108
    }
  },
  "errors": [],
  "license": "CC BY 4.0 - https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
  "citation": "Stanislav Peev, 'AI citations by question shape', stanislav-peev.com/research/ai-citations-by-query-shape/, 2026-09-07"
}